Websites

Too many subscriptions? Here’s how to actually fix it

Check your bank statement from the last 30 days and count the direct debits under $20. Most people get to six or seven before they stop recognising a name. That’s the real shape of the subscriptions problem in Australia right now: not one big expensive mistake, but a dozen small ones that each feel too trivial to cancel.

We’ve spent a fair bit of time this year going through reader emails about exactly this, usually prompted by a bank statement nobody expected. The pattern is remarkably consistent. A streaming service kept “just for one show”, a cloud storage plan upgraded during a phone setup and never downgraded, a fitness app from January’s resolution, a design tool a freelance gig needed for one month in 2024. None of it is a scam. All of it adds up. Managing too many subscriptions isn’t really a tech skill, it’s closer to a household budgeting problem that happens to live inside your phone.

How we got here

The subscription model used to be reserved for things with ongoing costs: pay TV, gym memberships, magazines delivered to a letterbox. Software was something you bought once, on a disc, and owned until it stopped working. That shift away from ownership is now close to total. Operating systems nudge you toward cloud storage subscriptions, productivity software is rented by the month, even some printer ink is sold as a subscription now.

The dry version: recurring revenue is simply better for a company’s share price than one-off sales, so almost everything has been re-engineered to bill monthly. It’s a sound business decision for the company. It’s a less sound one for the household unless you’re actually tracking it.

We’d argue this echoes something from the early days of mobile plans, when telcos bundled in call credit, data and handset repayments into one number that was deliberately hard to unpick. The subscription economy has done the same trick at a larger scale, just with better app design.

Our take: the industry didn’t force this on anyone, but it did make forgetting the default setting.

Doing the audit properly

Skip the budgeting apps for a moment and start with the primary sources. Apple ID subscriptions live under Settings, then your name, then Subscriptions. Google Play subscriptions sit inside the Play Store under Payments and subscriptions. If you bank with one of the big four, most banking apps now have a recurring payments or subscriptions view that scans your transaction history for repeating merchants, which catches the ones that bypass the app stores entirely, like a gym direct debit or a software licence billed straight to a credit card.

This is the bit people skip because it’s slightly tedious, and it’s the bit that actually matters. An app store subscription list only shows what was bought through that store. It won’t show a Netflix or Stan subscription paid by card, a cloud backup service billed annually, or a VPN you signed up to during a flight delay two years ago. You need both views, store and bank statement, to see the whole picture.

Give yourself twenty minutes with a spreadsheet, or honestly just a notes app, and list every recurring charge with its amount and billing date. Most people doing this for the first time find at least one subscription they’d genuinely forgotten existed.

What it actually costs across a year

A single $12.99 monthly subscription doesn’t register as a problem. Multiply it across streaming video, streaming music, a couple of cloud storage tiers, a news subscription, a fitness app and a password manager, and a household can easily be paying several hundred dollars a month without a single purchase feeling like a decision. Annualise that and it’s not a rounding error, it’s closer to a small appliance or a decent chunk of an overseas flight.

The ACCC’s cost of living work has flagged recurring subscriptions as a growing source of consumer complaints, particularly around services that are easy to join and deliberately slower to leave. That’s not a conspiracy theory, it’s a design pattern with a name in UX circles: the asymmetric exit, where sign-up takes one tap and cancellation takes a phone call, a retention offer, and sometimes a second phone call.

Cutting without losing everything you value

The instinct when you see the total is to cancel everything and start again, which usually backfires within a fortnight because you re-subscribe to the two or three things you actually used. A better approach is ranking, not purging.

  • Sort the list by cost per use, not cost per month. A $22 streaming service watched four nights a week is cheap. A $9.99 app opened twice in six months is expensive.
  • Look for genuine overlap. Two cloud storage subscriptions because a phone defaulted to one and a laptop defaulted to another is common, and usually only one is needed once you consolidate.
  • Check for a family or household tier before cancelling anything outright. Several streaming and storage services offer a shared plan that works out cheaper per person than everyone running their own.

We’ll admit a mildly contrarian view here: rotating subscriptions on and off, rather than running everything in parallel all year, is underrated. Subscribe to a streaming service for the two months a season you actually watch, cancel, move to the next one. Readers tend to treat subscriptions as fixed infrastructure, like the internet connection itself, when most of them are closer to a tap you can turn off. The services obviously don’t want you to think of it that way, which is itself a reason to.

Dealing with the subscriptions that fight back

Some cancellations are a three-tap job. Others require finding a specific menu buried three screens deep, or calling a number during limited hours, or sitting through a retention offer designed to make cancelling feel like a mistake. This isn’t accidental complexity. If you hit a wall, a few things help: cancel through the same channel you subscribed with (app store subscriptions can often be killed faster through Apple or Google than through the original company’s own app), screenshot confirmation emails, and if a company keeps charging after a confirmed cancellation, that’s a matter for your bank’s dispute process or, if it persists, a complaint through the ACCC, which tracks unfair sign-up and cancellation practices as part of its consumer protection work.

Verdict on the sticky ones: treat an unreasonably hard cancellation process as a signal about the company, not just an inconvenience to push through.

The security angle nobody budgets for

Every subscription is also an account, and every account is a password stored somewhere, sometimes on a card you’ve since cancelled, sometimes on an email address you no longer check. Old, abandoned subscription accounts are exactly the kind of low-effort target that shows up in data breach dumps, because nobody’s watching them. If part of your audit turns up an account you haven’t logged into in two years, it’s worth deleting it properly rather than letting it sit there with your card details and personal information attached. The OAIC’s Notifiable Data Breaches scheme publishes regular reports on exactly this kind of exposure, and dormant accounts are disproportionately represented in them.

If you’re clearing out old devices as part of the same tidy-up, it’s worth doing it properly rather than just deleting the app, which is covered in our guide on how to wipe an old phone or laptop properly before you sell or hand it down.

Software subscriptions deserve a separate look

Streaming and fitness apps get most of the attention, but software subscriptions are where real money leaks quietly, particularly for anyone running a side hustle or small business. Design tools, accounting software, cloud backup for business files, password managers with business tiers: these are often billed annually, which makes them easy to forget until the renewal notice lands. If you’re a sole trader, it’s worth lining this up against our broader piece on cyber security basics for sole traders, because several of the subscriptions worth keeping, like a decent password manager or backup service, are the same ones that double as your security baseline. Cutting the wrong one to save $8 a month can be a false economy.

On the storage side specifically, it’s common to find a household paying for upgraded cloud storage on two or three different platforms because nobody ever consolidated. We’ve written before about how little free storage Microsoft actually gives you by default and why that pushes people into paid tiers faster than they expect, which is worth a read if OneDrive is one of the line items on your list: why Microsoft’s OneDrive name isn’t exclusive covers some of the naming confusion that trips people up when comparing plans.

Setting a ceiling and sticking to it

The most durable fix isn’t a one-off audit, because subscriptions creep back in within months. It’s setting a household ceiling, a total dollar figure across all recurring services, and treating any new subscription as something that has to replace an existing one rather than stack on top. This is roughly how people manage phone plans once they’ve been burned by bill shock, and it transfers neatly. If your household already has a monthly ceiling in mind for connectivity, our explainer on NBN speed tiers and what your household actually needs is a reasonable model for the same exercise applied to internet rather than apps: work out what you actually use, not what sounds impressive on a feature list.

A calendar reminder every six months to re-run the audit is unglamorous, but it’s the single highest-value five minutes in this whole process.

Our verdict on the subscription habit

None of this requires cancelling everything or living like it’s 2006. Plenty of subscriptions are genuinely good value, particularly ones used daily. The problem has never really been subscriptions as a model, it’s the gap between what we signed up for and what we’re still using, a gap that grows quietly because nobody sends a reminder when a habit changes. Twenty minutes with a bank statement twice a year closes most of that gap. Fair dinkum, it’s not exciting work, but it’s one of the few bits of digital housekeeping that pays for itself within the hour.

— Dale Whitfield, Founding Editor, Tech Geek

Dale Whitfield

Dale Whitfield is the Founding Editor of Tech Geek. He set the brief the site still runs on — clear, useful technology journalism with no hype — and writes its bigger news analysis pieces. Dale has spent years following how technology companies behave and translating their announcements into what they actually mean for readers.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button